Research methods guide
How to trace a review claim to the original study
Start with the exact sentence and its citation in the review. Open the cited item, resolve the DOI or PMID, and find the primary study’s relevant result, table, or methods passage.
A review says an intervention “reduces readmission” but cites another review. Trace the specific claim to studies that actually measured readmission.
Turn a citation chain into a reproducible record
This is a synthetic chain. Preserve metadata and a source location at every level.
| Item | Worked example | Verification |
|---|---|---|
| First review | Discussion paragraph 2 claims “reduced readmission” and cites reference 18. | Record the claim and reference number and resolve the cited item. |
| Intermediate review | Table 3 lists two studies, one measuring only emergency revisits. | Trace both studies and identify which outcome matches the claim. |
| Primary study | Table 2 reports 30-day readmission in a single-center sample. | Verify groups, time window, estimate, and design before narrowing the statement. |
Apply the method to your materials
Preserve the chain and evidence boundary
Record review sentence, citation number, identifiers at each level, page or table, and scope of support. Mark abstract-only checks.
Align population and outcome separately
Split a multi-study claim if outcomes differ. Link multiple reports of the same cohort under a shared study ID.
Questions that arise in practice
Should I still cite the review?
Cite the primary study for its particular result and the review for broader synthesis when both are useful. Specify what each source supports.
Verified sources
The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.
RigorMed workspace
Start with your research materials
Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.
