Research methods guide
Title and abstract screening for systematic reviews
Screen titles and abstracts against prespecified criteria. Record clear exclusions and advance uncertain records for full-text assessment.
In a worked review of randomized trials of telephone follow-up after adult hospital discharge, exclude clearly ineligible records at abstract screening and retrieve uncertain records.
Two-reviewer screening log
The examples show how to calibrate ambiguous judgments while retaining independent decisions.
| Item | Worked example | Verification |
|---|---|---|
| R014 | Adult discharges randomized to usual care or phone follow-up. Both advance. | Retrieve full text to verify intervention and outcome. |
| R021 | Abstract says controlled study without allocation details. Reviewer A uncertain, B excludes. | Check full-text Methods. Retain original votes and clarify the rule. |
| R032 | Pediatric-only discharge cohort with no telephone intervention. Both exclude. | Code the first clear failure for auditing. |
Apply the method to your materials
Calibrate before independent screening
Use a set containing clear and borderline records. Agree on advancement and reconciliation rules before independent work.
Adjudicate unresolved conflicts
Save independent votes, consensus decision, adjudicator and rationale. Use page or paragraph references at full-text review.
Questions that arise in practice
Can an abstract without the primary outcome be excluded?
Check the protocol and whether the outcome could appear only in the full text before making that decision.
Verified sources
The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.
RigorMed workspace
Start with your research materials
Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.
