RigorMed
← Research resources

Research methods guide

How to write a point-by-point response to reviewers

Quote each comment and answer it with the action taken and the revised page, line, or table. Explain the evidence or constraints behind any request you did not adopt.

Journal submission and revisions

A reviewer asks about missing outcomes and proposes a severity variable unavailable in the dataset. Pair each comment with action, result and location.

Copyable point-by-point response format

Numbers and line locations are examples. Use the final submission.

Copyable point-by-point response format
ItemWorked exampleVerification
R1-1, missing dataComment: Explain missing day-90 outcomes. Response: We added counts (4/100 and 3/100), reasons and an all-missing-as-events sensitivity analysis.Cite Methods lines 112–118, Results 184–187 and Table S2.
R1-2, unavailable variableComment: Adjust for severity. Response: The source lacks a common severity scale. We added a utilization-proxy analysis and described residual confounding.State proxy limitations and cite the supplement and Discussion.
R2-1, overlapping commentAnswer the specific question, summarize the change and link to R1-1 and the updated locations.Preserve each comment ID so the editor can reconcile them.

Apply the method to your materials

  1. Create a tracking sheet first

    Preserve comment, owner, action, location, result and status. Split multi-part requests into individual checks.

  2. Update locations from the final submission

    Reconcile clean and marked copies and disclose any change to the main conclusion.

Questions that arise in practice

How do I disagree with a reviewer?

Acknowledge the concern, give design or data reasons, and document feasible verification, revisions and residual limits.

Verified sources

The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.

  1. Nature: Effective response to reviewers

RigorMed workspace

Start with your research materials

Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.