RigorMed
← Research resources

Research methods guide

How to check discrepancies between a paper and its abstract

When the abstract and full text differ, check whether they describe the same outcome, time point, analysis population, and model. Then locate both numbers in the results tables and notes.

Reading and reference verification

In this synthetic example, the abstract reports 500 enrolled participants and a 12-week result, while the main model in Table 2 contains 428. Determine which counts refer to enrollment, follow-up, or analysis.

Put the abstract and full text in one reconciliation table

Compare one outcome, time point, and population at a time.

Put the abstract and full text in one reconciliation table
ItemWorked exampleVerification
Counts500 in the abstract and 428 in the main model.Trace the 72 through the flow diagram, model n, and missing-data notes. If reasons are absent, mark them unresolved.
Timing12 weeks in the abstract and 24 weeks in Table 2.Check the protocol and Methods for separate time points and look for corrections.
EstimateAbstract OR 1.20, with crude OR 1.05 also reported in Table 2.Verify the model column and adjustments. Identify the estimate explicitly when citing it.

Apply the method to your materials

  1. Assign a discrepancy ID

    Record the item, both locations, model or denominator, decision, and follow-up. Check footnotes and supplements, then check the publisher’s version and record access date.

  2. Name the analysis set in your citation

    If Table 2 uses complete cases, write “the main model included 428 complete cases.” Leave unresolved conflicts open for clarification or formal correction.

Questions that arise in practice

Does the full text always take precedence?

Use the location that identifies the model, population, and time point, taking supplements and formal corrections into account. Disclose unresolved conflicts.

Verified sources

The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.

  1. ICMJE Recommendations for Manuscript Preparation

RigorMed workspace

Start with your research materials

Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.