Research methods guide
How to peer-review a systematic review search
Give an independent reviewer the review question, eligibility rules, database strategies, and several known relevant studies. Check concepts, grouping, fields, controlled vocabulary, spelling, and any date or language limits.
In this worked example a colleague searches PubMed for asthma, inhaled corticosteroids and lung function. The review identifies retrieval and syntax errors and documents the before and after queries.
How to write PRESS feedback
Record location, consequence, suggestion and retest so the author can respond to each item.
| Item | Worked example | Verification |
|---|---|---|
| Boolean grouping | Change asthma OR wheezing AND budesonide to (asthma OR wheezing) AND budesonide. | Inspect Search Details and test with an asthma record that does not contain budesonide. |
| Spelling and synonyms | Budesonide alone misses eligible drugs such as fluticasone if included by the protocol. | Compare drug names with eligibility and known studies, then inspect incremental hits. |
| Limits and coverage | Requiring FEV1 may lose trials reporting it only in the full text. | Compare with and without the outcome block using known trials and sample incremental records. |
Apply the method to your materials
Match each block to the question
Read eligibility, then review headings, free text, fields, proximity and limits. Identify the exact strategy affected.
Retest after edits
Record the decision on each comment and save both strategy versions and dates. Rerun the known missed records.
Questions that arise in practice
Does PRESS select the largest result set?
Judge coverage against the question, eligibility and known records. Counts help diagnose changes and should be paired with inspection.
Verified sources
The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.
RigorMed workspace
Start with your research materials
Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.
