RigorMed
← Research resources

Research methods guide

How to check numerical consistency in a manuscript

Use the analysis output or reviewed results table as the numeric source of truth. Reconcile repeated values across the abstract, text, figures, and supplement.

Manuscript writing and editing

An abstract reports 12.0% readmitted while the table shows 12/96. Trace the analysis output to distinguish denominator, rounding and version errors.

Numerical reconciliation log

Record source, manuscript location, current value, correction and reviewer.

Numerical reconciliation log
ItemWorked exampleVerification
DenominatorAbstract 12.0%, table 12/96 = 12.5%; if an analysis uses 100, document missing-data treatment.Match the analysis population and do not silently change a percentage.
Estimate and directionText says +3.4 mmHg while intervention minus control is −3.4 (−5.9 to −0.9).Align reference groups and reverse interval bounds when reversing the contrast.
RoundingOutput P=0.0496 appears as 0.050 to three decimals.Follow journal precision and avoid conflicts from rounding near a threshold.

Apply the method to your materials

  1. Freeze the analysis version

    Export a single value sheet with group, unit, version, script and cutoff, and map it to tables and figures.

  2. Have a second reader verify backwards

    Sample primary results, abstract, legends, supplement and response letter. Log changes and check the final PDF.

Questions that arise in practice

Must rounded percentages sum to 100%?

Verify denominators and missingness. If independent rounding explains it, note it and retain reproducible counts.

Verified sources

The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.

  1. ICMJE Recommendations for Manuscript Preparation

RigorMed workspace

Start with your research materials

Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.