Research methods guide
What journal submission statuses usually mean
A manuscript status describes its position in the workflow. Consult the journal’s explanation and formal decision letter, since journals can configure the labels.
When a portal shows With Editor or Under Review, consult the journal's definitions and check messages and requested actions. The stages below are illustrative.
Statuses and observable signals
Names differ by journal and publisher. Check dates and actual actions in the submission record.
| Item | Worked example | Verification |
|---|---|---|
| Technical check or editor handling | Staff may verify files or assign an editor. Act on a documented request to correct the submission. | Check email, portal tasks, manuscript ID and requested replacement files. |
| Under Review | The paper may be at reviewer invitation or assessment, depending on the journal. | Check local status definitions; the generic label does not reveal review count. |
| Decision in Process | The editor may be preparing a decision. Use the official decision letter or portal notice. | Keep the timeline and follow the journal's published turnaround and contact guidance. |
Apply the method to your materials
Keep a timeline
Record submission, returns, resubmissions, status changes and messages. Prioritize explicit requests.
Provide concise details when enquiring
If published timing is exceeded or messages conflict, use the journal contact route with ID, title, last status and date.
Questions that arise in practice
Does returning to With Editor signal rejection?
Labels can recur at different stages. Check decision letters, tasks and the journal's definitions.
Verified sources
The official sources below were checked on 2026-11-12. Access conditions and update dates are rechecked before publication.
RigorMed workspace
Start with your research materials
Bring your research question, available materials, and the steps you want to check.
